Although I do think your rule is reasonable, I am not sure that I would be bothered with it for a temporary care situation. I guess it depends if the other kids notice and complain (depends on their ages), but I wouldn't force him to try it if he's eaten his other food. I actually just serve 2-3 items for a lunch and they eat what they want and leave what they don't like. I like your rule, but wouldn't have the energy to force picky toddlers to try things they don't eat at home![]()