When I did after school care I would offer about 2x the amount of food that you are. Another option is to leave out a bowl of cut up veggies or fruit for those who are still hungry after snack is finished. BTW my afterschoolers were mostly boys if that makes a difference.
If you visited or if you're using a childcare provider found on DaycareBear, do not hesitate to leave a review. This will most certainly help other parents!
Updates
We expect providers to keep their listing and available openings up-to-date. However, to prevent oversights, openings expire after 45 days.