agree with reggio and dreamalittledream: on the fact that "at least these parents are recognizing "negative" behavior and responding to it" I personally wouldn't choose this form....but thats only my opinion. (I give a verbal warning followed in "severe circumstances" with a quick slap on the lips or a spanking for disrespect and talking back) Don't expect everyone to agree with my choice of punishment either...that's just what works for ME! To each his own when raising their own child, my only concern is when the punishment crosses the line from "punishment to abuse" that can happen with any form of punishment, "soap in mouth" "books on head" "spanking" "push-ups"...parents HAVE TO use their best judgement and know when "enough is enough", hopefully they do!