I'll be the first it chime in and admit. I LOVE presents! I used to shower my provider with gifts and I absolutely expect the same.
Last year gifts ranged from a candle holder (which is a bit of a pain because you have to bring it out every year so that the little one knows you still have it) to a $100 gift card to a restaurant.
I personally like starbucks cards. Since I don't have the advantage of driving to starbucks every morning I make sure I have high quality coffee in the house at all time. My guilty pleasure I guess.
I also enjoy restaurant gift cards, movie gift certificates are nice.
I don't like... baked good... wine (never seems to be what I like) ... nic naks.