$500 annually for 5MIL liability sounds like a good deal to me. Those who pay less may very well have less coverage. A minimum of 1MIL per child in care is advisable. 1 or 2 MIL between a group of 5 or 6 isn't going to go very far should the worst happen to your group and all families sue!
If you are having problems with housing and insurance, this tip https://augustafreepress.com/all-you...ance-twisting/ may help. It is known that most people have trouble with insurance companies when it comes to insurance twisting.