She doesn't get it

So I have a 2 yo DCG who when she wakes from her nap sings, yells etc. I have all the kids in one room for naps. Now she just isn't or doesn't want to get it that she has to be quiet once she wakes up. Some days are better than others but today is particularly bad, we're talking about "Frere Jacques" belted out. Kind of cute if I can look at it from the outside and not as the person trying to have a break sans kids. I tell her "no talking" on the monitor and I went down, laid her down, said no talking" and took her stuffed dog (they loose them if they goof around at nap). She just doesn't care. She is a bit of a "bugger" in general but super cute so she does get a way with stuff. Her parents just said "Oh suzy" when she does something so I am not sure what other consequences she has at home. She is also y one kid on a completely different schedule than the rest of my DC kids. She goes to bed super late (9-9:30), wakes late (they have a hard time getting her to me for 9 which is the latest I will accept her). I really don't want to move her up to another room as my daughter uses her room when she is sick, has PD days or for the summer etc. In our room just isn't ideal either for those times my husband is sick or home for whatever reason. I did this once before and it just didn't work out...other ideas?

If they talk etc when they wake up they are also consequenced in that they have to stay on their cot/playpen on a time out until the other kids are up and changed.

I use my laundry room for the disruptive kids. Luckily my group right now is fairly good. If someone is being noisy I just have to tell them once but the others are good at sleeping through it. I also have a big square fan in there on high to drown out noise.

Could you find a way to block her view of the other kids? Room divider, or something? And a white noise machine?

Generally, I am the opposite. When they are old enough to be on a bed (I use crib mattresses) and out of the playpen (Around 2yrs) then I expect they are to come out of the sleep room when they wake up. This is hard for some of them, even till they're 4-5, but that is the rule. They come out and play quietly or look at books till nap is over.

When they are still in the playpen, I will use the particular needs of the child to determine if it's time to get up. If they are soo cranky... then its back to bed. Also, if they get up shortly after I leave the room then it's back to bed too cuz obviously they weren't asleep when I left.

Some kids don't need as much rest as others. She not actually doing anything wrong. She awake and laying there in silence when so little even for a few mins is a long time. She's waking up and entertaining herself just not how you want her to.

Is it a big deal to get her up and let her play independently in the play room?

How long has she been asleep before she wake up, all fresh and raring to go?

I'd let her get up but understand that some carers insist on children stay in nap room for hours even if wide awake. If that not work for you, then another room is only option. Big ask to expect small child to stay in the crib and do so silently if they have napped and are recharged.

see im the opposite ...i use my bedrooms for naps and im not going to lose my break time everyday just because there may be the odd time that one of my children or hubby is home ...there are other places for them to go if they are and i get 2.5-3 hours of break everyday

I am of the school that the children do need to be quiet during nap. She has books on her cot if she wakes up, she doesn't need to sing and be loud. The kids all sleep in the play room so I don't want to start allowing them to go and play or there will be no break, just kids playing with me checking on them constantly.

All the kids here learn to be quiet during nap time. For the most part it works really well until I have a bad day here or there. I guess because I am used to the 2.5 hrs of quiet time, when it doesn't happen I notice it! I think I will try and run a humidifier near her to work as white noise. If she quietly sings to herself I don't care...it is the belting out in song and waking the other kids that doesn't work for me.

Aside from my daughter or my bedroom we don't have anywhere else that would fit a cot/be dark. My laundry room is off the kitchen and bright. I already use things in the playroom as visual barriers, I move the playhouse out to block off one playpen from the other, put the trampoline in front of another etc.

Hmmm....wish I had a suggestion..I too have a little one that sleeps in...sometimes doesn't come til 10-10:30...of course she is not going to nap....but I DON'T have any of the children in the same room at nap time....I have earned my "time" while they nap...so the one that comes late can talk to herself in her room all she wants! lol

I don't really have any suggestions :(

I nap all mine in the same room and all I do is place them in playpen/cot, cover them up, say goodnight, turn on white noise machine and leave. They are sleeping by the time I get upstairs and turn the monitor on!! However...the youngest (19 month-ish) will sometimes wake up 30-60 minutes before the rest of them. She too is a singer and a chatter!! I speak over the monitor and tell her to lie down. She usually listens but I can still hear her chatting sometimes lol. She will usually fall back asleep. If she doesn't and it's getting too disruptive for the others, I go get her.

It's only occasional with her but in the past if I've had a noisy napper, I put them in a playpen in my dc kitchen. I have to keep the playpen in my adjoining laundry room which is kinda in the way but I'd rather do this than have their naps disrupted.